Fulmination, Ruminations, and Snacks from a Resurgent Author

Mailing List

Click here to join my Warped Space newsletter. Freebies and perqs come with your subscription, too.

Unusual New SF Novella!

Teramis is back, with her first story collection published in more than a decade. Make a great escape to her science fiction universe with the armchair traveler tales in this book. Click here for more!

Free Fantasy Novel

Help yourself to a free copy of Dragonsword, the first fantasy novel from Deborah Teramis Christian in over a decade. Now available for immediate download at the Dragonsword book site, or you can read an excerpt here.

Enter your email to subscribe to

Delivered by FeedBurner


Random Posts

Product polls show popularity, not quality

Download PDF

I am in urgent need of a sophisticated, high-powered feed reader.  So I’m looking at reviews and commentary on same, when I came across this statement:   “I ran a poll to find out which is the best feed reader.”

Now, don’t bother googling that; I’ve paraphrased so as not to embarass the well-intentioned author with my imminent snark, which is certainly not meant personally.  But I really see this kind of thinking entirely too often, and wonder why people even waste their time.  Come on, now:  a poll to determine “best” product? What foolishness.

All that this kind of  poll can tell the pollster is what products are commonly used – that is, which products are most popular with the users who chanced across the site’s unscientific and simplistic poll widget.   That’s it.

Polls in this context are nothing more than a popularity contest. This is perfectly fine if your question is actually “what’s most popular among you who read this?”  It’s a terrible idea, though, if your question is really meant to be, “what is the best?”

“Best” is subjective judgment.  To give it any validity, we have to know what needs a thing must fulfill, and know how well the thing accomplishes that.  Sure, we’re used to making subjective judgments every day, but at the bottom of  effective decision-making – design and QA disciplines come to mind – there is always a criteria against which performance is evaluated and judged. At the end of that evaluation process, then we might be able to say what is “best” for a given purpose and set of requirements.

We need to know how the thing works relative to your needs.

A person doesn’t need to come from a structured design background to understand or utilize this process in selecting the right tools for the job.  But one might do well to resist for a moment the urge to tap into the group mind for the instant gratification of a hasty opinion ping.  The right first step is to ask, “what does this tool need to do for me?” and communicate that factoid to the group mind as basis for the ensuing discussion.

Then, poll or not, we might get some feedback that actually leads to “what’s right for me”  –  not “what’s best for them.”

Leave a Reply

Author Deborah Teramis Christian

Teramis wrote her first book at age 9, but like all good literary lizards has taken her time charging upon the market. Finally in a situation where she can write full time, she is becoming the Dragon, Unleashed, or a close facsimile thereof. Roar, said the saur.

Teramis On the Web

Alternate History Weekly Update - Guest Blogging

MilSciFi Interview - re "Live Fire" in No Man's Land

New Books

This military science fiction anthology contains "Live Fire," Christian's Tiptree Award-nominated short story set in the Sa'adani Empire, the setting of her science fiction novels. Now available at Amazon in print and Kindle editions.